How Bad Was Sithanen?

His nine-year-old economic reforms have been an unmitigated mess. Plenty has been written about this. For example his policies have been worse than flipping a coin. A roulette in the Treasury Building would have produced even better outcomes. Which gives you an idea of the kind of skills mismatch we're talking about here. But let's look at it from a different perspective given how sophisticated Mauritian voters have shown us they can be.

Mr. Sithanen claims that he saved the economy. If that's the case then why didn't he:

1. get a ticket from Ramgoolam in 2010?

2. get a MMM ticket in 2010 after asking voters to punish one fils a papa who had betrayed him?

3. stand as an independent candidate in no. 18 in 2010? Dr. Sithanen was after all a force to reckon with in Belle-Rose/Quatre-Bornes. Not anymore.

Because if you analyse electoral data you'll find out that the people of Mauritius are able to express a whole range of feelings. For example and as the chart illustrates Sir Veerasamy Ringadoo -- our Minister of Finance for a long time -- had no problem facing the music in 1982 and even got 20% of the votes in his riding. Because SVR knew that he had done his best. Nine years later Lutchmeenaraidoo ran as a candidate for a party other than the one which had made him Finance Minister for eight years and still managed to get 46% of the votes. Fast forward nine years again and we have voters expressing an amount of sympathy towards former Police Commissioner Raj Dayal that almost got him into Parliament.

Plus Sithanen could have counted on powerful friends in the media to manufacture a convenient reality and on Ali Mansoor who would have made a wonderful campaign manager. He didn't run as a candidate because practically everybody knew -- him included -- he was unelectable because his second term as FM had been a reign of costly and crazy economic errors and that payback time had arrived.

Four and half years later he might still be one of the three reasons why when election results are announced on December 11, Ramgoolam will command a lot fewer MPs than he did recently.

© Sanjay Jagatsingh, 2014